Minimum Roof Slope? The ULTIMATE Guide You NEED to See!

Understanding the minimum slope for roof is crucial for homeowners and construction professionals alike. Roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles, each have specific slope requirements detailed in guidelines provided by organizations like the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA). Building codes, which often reference engineering principles, dictate the acceptable minimum slope for roof based on factors like climate and drainage requirements. Adhering to these specifications, often calculated and confirmed by licensed roofing contractors, prevents water damage and ensures the longevity of the roof structure.

What's the minimum slope you'd recommend for a roof?

Image taken from the YouTube channel HomeShowRadio , from the video titled What’s the minimum slope you’d recommend for a roof? .

Table of Contents

Why Minimum Roof Slope Matters: Protecting Your Investment from the Top Down

The roof over your head is more than just shelter; it’s a critical component protecting your entire property and its contents from the elements. A seemingly simple factor, the minimum roof slope, plays a pivotal role in ensuring that your roof performs as intended for decades to come.

But what exactly is minimum roof slope, and why should homeowners and builders alike be so concerned with it?

Defining Minimum Roof Slope

Minimum roof slope refers to the least amount of incline a roof can have while still effectively shedding water and preventing moisture intrusion. It’s typically expressed as a ratio of rise (vertical height) over run (horizontal distance), such as 4/12 (meaning 4 inches of rise for every 12 inches of horizontal distance).

Understanding this seemingly simple number is crucial because it dictates the types of roofing materials that can be safely and effectively installed on a given roof.

The Significance of Adequate Slope

Adequate roof slope is absolutely essential for the long-term health and performance of your roof. It allows gravity to do its job, efficiently channeling rainwater, snowmelt, and debris off the roof surface and away from vulnerable areas like seams, flashing, and penetrations.

Without sufficient slope, water can pool, leading to a cascade of problems.

Consequences of Insufficient Slope: A Recipe for Disaster

Roofs that lack adequate slope are prone to a variety of issues, all of which can lead to costly repairs and significant damage.

Roof leaks are the most immediate and obvious consequence. Pooled water can find its way through even the smallest imperfections in the roofing material, leading to:

  • Water stains on ceilings and walls.
  • Mold and mildew growth, which can pose health risks.
  • Rotting of structural components, such as rafters and sheathing.

Over time, these problems can compromise the structural integrity of the entire building.

Adhering to Standards: Codes, Guidelines, and Regulations

Selecting the right roofing material and ensuring proper installation according to the minimum slope requirements is paramount.

Building codes, manufacturer guidelines, and local regulations all play a critical role in determining the appropriate slope for a given roofing material and geographic location. These standards are designed to ensure the safety and longevity of the roof, protecting both the building and its occupants. Ignoring these guidelines can lead to serious problems, including voided warranties, code violations, and, ultimately, a roof that fails prematurely.

Understanding Roof Slope: The Basics

Before delving into specific material requirements and code considerations, it’s crucial to establish a solid understanding of roof slope itself. This involves grasping how it’s measured, the terminology used to describe it, and the key differences between low-slope and steep-slope roofs.

Measuring and Expressing Roof Slope

Roof slope is quantified as the ratio of its vertical rise to its horizontal run. The "run" is a fixed value of 12 inches, simplifying the ratio. Therefore, a roof that rises 4 inches for every 12 inches of horizontal distance is said to have a slope of 4/12.

This "rise over run" ratio is the most common way to express roof slope in the United States. It is a fraction; however, it is generally referred to as " in 12". For example: "four in twelve", or "four over twelve".

Slope, Pitch, and Angle: Decoding the Terminology

While often used interchangeably, slope, pitch, and angle represent slightly different, though related, concepts. Slope, as described above, is the rise-over-run ratio. Pitch, though less commonly used today, is the rise-over-span ratio, where the "span" is the distance between the exterior walls of the structure.

The angle, on the other hand, refers to the degrees of inclination from a perfectly horizontal plane. While slope is expressed as a ratio, angle is expressed in degrees. Online calculators can easily convert between slope and angle if needed.

Understanding these terms and their subtle distinctions is essential for clear communication with roofing professionals and for accurately interpreting building codes and manufacturer specifications.

Low-Slope vs. Steep-Slope Roofs: Drawing the Line

The classification of a roof as either low-slope or steep-slope is critical because it dictates the types of roofing materials that are appropriate and the installation techniques that must be employed. The definition depends on the specific material and code requirements, but a general guideline is as follows:

  • Low-Slope Roofs: Typically have a slope of 3/12 or less. At these lower slopes, water runoff is slower, and the risk of water penetration is significantly higher. Therefore, low-slope roofs generally require roofing materials specifically designed to be waterproof or have superior waterproofing characteristics, such as modified bitumen, TPO, or EPDM.

  • Steep-Slope Roofs: Have a slope greater than 3/12. The steeper the slope, the faster the water runoff, and the less susceptible the roof is to water penetration. A wider variety of roofing materials, including asphalt shingles, tile, and metal roofing, can be used on steep-slope roofs. Higher slopes require more care for workers.

The distinction between low-slope and steep-slope roofs isn’t always a hard line. Some materials can be used on roofs with slopes near this "border", but require modifications or specific installation methods. Always consult manufacturer specifications and local building codes to determine the suitability of a particular roofing material for a given slope.

Minimum Slope Requirements by Roofing Material

With a firm grasp of how roof slope is measured and defined, we can now turn our attention to the specific slope requirements dictated by the roofing material itself. Choosing the right roofing material involves more than aesthetics; it demands a thorough understanding of its performance characteristics, particularly its ability to shed water effectively at a given slope.

Each material possesses a minimum slope threshold below which its waterproofing capabilities are compromised, leading to potential leaks and premature failure. Let’s examine the minimum slope requirements for some of the most common roofing materials:

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are a popular and economical choice for many homeowners. Generally, asphalt shingles require a minimum slope of 2/12.

This means that for every 12 inches of horizontal run, the roof must rise at least 2 inches. However, there are important caveats.

For slopes between 2/12 and 4/12, often termed "low-slope" applications for asphalt shingles, a double layer of underlayment or a modified bitumen membrane is typically required beneath the shingles. This provides an extra layer of protection against water infiltration.

Some premium asphalt shingles are rated for slopes as low as 1/12 with specific underlayment systems. Always consult the manufacturer’s specifications for the particular shingle you are considering. Factors like climate, expected rainfall, and ice damming potential also influence suitability. In colder climates with heavy snowfall, steeper slopes are generally preferred.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing offers durability, longevity, and aesthetic appeal. However, minimum slope requirements vary significantly based on the type of metal roofing system.

Standing seam metal roofs are known for their weathertightness and can often be installed on slopes as low as 1/4:12 (some even lower depending on the manufacturer’s specifications). This is because the raised seams are designed to prevent water penetration.

Corrugated metal roofing, on the other hand, typically requires a steeper minimum slope, usually 3/12 or greater. The overlapping panels of corrugated metal rely on sufficient slope to quickly shed water.

The type of metal also matters. Steel, aluminum, and copper each have different expansion and contraction rates, which can affect the performance of seams and fasteners, particularly on low-slope roofs. Always refer to the manufacturer’s installation guidelines.

Tile Roofing

Tile roofing, including both clay and concrete tiles, provides exceptional durability and a distinctive aesthetic. However, tile roofs are heavy, and their weight places significant demands on the roof structure.

Clay and concrete tiles generally require a minimum slope of 3/12 or even 4/12. This steeper slope is necessary to ensure proper water runoff and to prevent water from being driven back under the tiles by wind.

The underlayment beneath tile roofs is crucial due to the tile’s susceptibility to wind-driven rain. Weight is a major consideration; the roof structure must be engineered to support the considerable load of the tile.

Additionally, the fastening system used to secure the tiles must be appropriate for the roof slope and wind conditions.

Wood Shakes

Wood shakes offer a rustic, natural look but have specific requirements regarding slope and maintenance. A minimum slope of 4/12 is generally recommended for wood shakes.

This steeper slope is essential for promoting rapid water runoff and preventing moisture from being trapped beneath the shakes, which can lead to rot and decay.

The type of wood also impacts suitability. Cedar shakes are naturally more resistant to decay than other wood species. Climate plays a critical role. In wetter climates, steeper slopes and proper ventilation are essential to prolong the life of wood shake roofs.

Regular maintenance, including cleaning and treatment with preservatives, is also necessary to ensure long-term performance.

Slate

Slate roofing is renowned for its exceptional longevity and natural beauty. However, it’s also one of the heaviest roofing materials and requires a robust roof structure and a steeper slope. Slate typically requires a minimum slope of 4/12.

Some installations may even require a steeper slope, especially in areas with heavy snowfall. The interlocking nature of slate tiles and their relatively small size contribute to their water resistance, but a sufficient slope is crucial to prevent water from pooling and potentially seeping between the tiles.

The Indispensable Role of Underlayment

Regardless of the roofing material selected, underlayment is a critical component of any roofing system. It serves as a secondary barrier against water infiltration, protecting the roof deck from moisture damage, especially if the primary roofing material fails or is compromised.

For all roofing materials, using the correct underlayment as specified by the roofing material manufacturer is critical. Some roofing types and applications will also benefit from a self-adhering waterproof underlayment which creates a completely sealed surface under your primary roof covering.

The Role of Roofing Codes and Regulations

While understanding the material-specific requirements is crucial, it’s equally vital to recognize that roofing projects are heavily governed by building codes and regulations. These codes aren’t arbitrary; they’re carefully crafted guidelines designed to ensure the safety, durability, and overall performance of roofing systems. Ignorance or disregard of these regulations can lead to costly rework, legal complications, and, most importantly, compromised structural integrity.

Understanding the IBC and IRC

Two of the most influential model building codes in the United States are the International Building Code (IBC), which primarily applies to commercial buildings, and the International Residential Code (IRC), which focuses on residential structures.

These codes provide comprehensive guidance on all aspects of construction, including roofing. They often reference industry standards and material specifications to establish minimum performance criteria. While the IBC and IRC themselves are not law, they serve as templates adopted and amended by state and local jurisdictions.

Therefore, it is crucial to understand that the local building code is the governing document for any specific project. These local adaptations may have more stringent requirements based on regional climate conditions, seismic activity, or other factors.

Navigating Local Building Codes

Finding and interpreting local building codes can seem daunting, but it’s a necessary step. Your local city or county government’s website is usually the best starting point. Look for the building department or planning department, as they are responsible for enforcing building codes.

Many jurisdictions now offer online access to their adopted codes. Review the roofing section carefully, paying close attention to the tables and figures that specify minimum slope requirements for various materials.

Pay close attention to any amendments or supplements that may have been added to the base code. These amendments often reflect local conditions or specific concerns. If you encounter any ambiguities or have questions, don’t hesitate to contact the building department directly for clarification.

The Value of a Licensed Roofing Contractor

Navigating the complexities of building codes is best left to experts. Engaging a licensed roofing contractor is paramount to ensuring compliance. These professionals are not only skilled in the practical aspects of roofing but also possess in-depth knowledge of local regulations.

A reputable contractor will be able to advise you on the appropriate roofing materials and installation techniques to meet code requirements. Furthermore, they will handle the permitting process, coordinate with building inspectors, and ensure that the project adheres to all applicable regulations.

Choosing a contractor without proper licensing and insurance is a significant risk. Such individuals may lack the necessary expertise and may not be accountable for any code violations or substandard work.

The Role of Building Inspectors

Building inspectors serve as the final line of defense in ensuring code compliance. They are employed by the local jurisdiction to inspect construction projects at various stages and verify that they meet the requirements of the building code.

Roofing inspections typically occur after the underlayment is installed and after the roofing material is applied. The inspector will examine the roof for proper slope, material installation, flashing details, and other critical elements.

Failure to pass an inspection can result in delays, fines, and the need for corrective action. By working with a licensed contractor who understands code requirements, you can minimize the risk of inspection failures and ensure a smooth project completion.

Factors Affecting Minimum Slope Requirements

While adherence to building codes and material specifications provides a crucial foundation for roofing decisions, it’s equally important to understand that minimum slope requirements aren’t etched in stone. Various environmental and design factors can significantly influence the optimal roof slope for a given structure. Ignoring these variables can lead to premature roof failure, even if the initial installation adheres to code.

Environmental Considerations

The local climate plays a pivotal role in determining the appropriate minimum roof slope. Regions with harsh weather conditions often necessitate steeper slopes to effectively manage water runoff and prevent long-term damage.

Rainfall and Slope

Areas experiencing high annual rainfall require roofs with sufficient slope to quickly shed water. Prolonged exposure to standing water can overwhelm roofing materials, leading to leaks and deterioration. The frequency of rainfall events is also a factor. Regions with frequent, smaller rainfalls might tolerate slightly lower slopes than those experiencing infrequent but intense downpours.

Snowfall and Load Management

Snow accumulation presents a different set of challenges. The weight of accumulated snow can place immense stress on a roof structure. Steeper slopes facilitate snow shedding, reducing the load and minimizing the risk of collapse.

However, uncontrolled snow slides can create hazards. Therefore, design should consider snow guards or other mitigating measures.

Wind Resistance

High wind zones demand careful consideration of roofing material selection and slope. Lower slopes generally offer better wind resistance, reducing the risk of uplift. However, extremely low slopes can create other problems related to water drainage.

The specific roofing material and its installation method are critical factors in mitigating wind damage.

Ice Dam Prevention

Ice dams form when melting snow refreezes at the roof’s edge, creating a barrier that prevents further runoff. Water then backs up under the roofing material, leading to leaks and significant water damage.

Steeper slopes, combined with proper insulation and ventilation, help minimize ice dam formation by promoting consistent roof temperatures and preventing snowmelt from refreezing at the eaves.

Design and Style Influences

Beyond environmental factors, the overall roof design and architectural style also impact minimum slope considerations.

Roof Complexity and Water Management

Complex roof designs, with numerous valleys, dormers, and penetrations, require steeper slopes to effectively channel water away from vulnerable areas. Valleys, in particular, are prone to water accumulation and require careful attention to slope and flashing details.

Span and Structural Integrity

The span of a roof, or the distance between supporting walls, influences the structural requirements and, consequently, the minimum slope. Larger spans may require steeper slopes to ensure adequate load-bearing capacity.

Roofing Pitch and Architectural Style

Different roofing styles often dictate specific pitch ranges. For example, gable roofs commonly feature moderate to steep slopes, while shed roofs typically have a single, shallow slope. Hip roofs, with their sloping sides, allow for a wider range of pitches.

The architectural style of a building can therefore influence the choice of roofing material and the corresponding minimum slope.

The impact of environmental factors and design choices on roof slope requirements is undeniable. However, even the most meticulous planning can be undermined by a failure to adhere to the established minimum slope guidelines. The repercussions of such oversights extend far beyond mere inconvenience.

Common Problems with Insufficient Roof Slope

Ignoring minimum roof slope specifications invites a host of problems that can compromise the integrity and longevity of a building. The immediate and long-term consequences range from persistent leaks to structural damage and significant financial burdens.

The Inevitable Roof Leaks

Perhaps the most common and immediate consequence of insufficient roof slope is the development of persistent roof leaks.

Roofs are designed to shed water effectively. When the slope is inadequate, water tends to pool or drain sluggishly.

This prolonged exposure allows water to seep through seams, under roofing materials, and into the underlying structure.

The result is not just an occasional drip, but a constant vulnerability to water intrusion.

Water Damage: A Cascade of Problems

Roof leaks are rarely isolated incidents. They trigger a cascade of water damage that can affect multiple areas of a building.

Ceilings, walls, and insulation can become saturated, leading to unsightly stains, mold growth, and compromised structural integrity.

Mold, in particular, poses serious health risks, especially for individuals with respiratory sensitivities.

Furthermore, water damage can extend to electrical systems, creating fire hazards and requiring costly repairs.

Premature Roof Failure and Shortened Lifespan

A roof installed with insufficient slope is subjected to undue stress and accelerated wear.

Pooling water and trapped moisture promote the deterioration of roofing materials, causing them to buckle, crack, or rot prematurely.

The lifespan of the roof is significantly reduced, requiring replacement far sooner than anticipated.

This not only results in unexpected expenses, but also disrupts building operations and potentially exposes the interior to further damage during the replacement process.

Voided Material Warranties

Roofing material manufacturers set stringent installation requirements, including minimum slope specifications.

Failure to comply with these requirements often voids the manufacturer’s warranty.

This means that if the roof fails prematurely due to insufficient slope, the building owner will bear the full cost of repairs or replacement, without any recourse to the manufacturer.

This can translate into a substantial financial loss, especially considering the significant investment involved in roofing projects.

Long-Term Structural Damage

The cumulative effect of water intrusion and material deterioration can lead to long-term structural damage to the building.

Rotting wood, corroded metal, and weakened foundations can compromise the stability of the entire structure.

In severe cases, this can necessitate extensive and costly repairs, or even render the building unsafe for occupancy.

Addressing structural damage is far more complex and expensive than simply replacing a roof. It requires specialized expertise and can disrupt building operations for extended periods.

The damage accumulates, diminishing the roof’s ability to withstand the elements and protect the structure beneath. This ultimately leads to premature roof failure and a significantly shortened lifespan, negating the initial investment and necessitating costly replacements far sooner than anticipated.

Ensuring Proper Roof Slope During Installation

While the selection of appropriate roofing materials and adherence to code are paramount, the execution of the installation process is equally critical in guaranteeing the intended performance of a roof. Even the best materials, chosen with the correct slope in mind, can fail if the installation is flawed.

The Cornerstone of Success: Meticulous Planning and Design

The foundation of a successful roofing project is laid long before the first nail is hammered. Comprehensive planning and precise design are essential to ensure that the finished roof meets all requirements, including the critical minimum slope.

This phase involves a detailed assessment of the building’s architectural plans, local climate conditions, and applicable building codes.

It demands that the designed roof pitch is not only aesthetically pleasing but also structurally sound and functionally appropriate.

Accurate calculations and careful selection of materials should be completed.

The planning phase establishes a clear roadmap for the entire project.

The Indispensable Role of Experienced Roofing Contractors

A roofing project’s success hinges largely on the expertise and experience of the roofing contractor. Choosing a qualified, licensed, and insured contractor is a critical decision.

These professionals possess the necessary knowledge and skills to interpret architectural plans, understand building codes, and execute the installation with precision.

Their expertise ensures the roof is installed according to industry best practices and manufacturer specifications.

Experienced contractors are adept at identifying potential issues during the installation process, such as unexpected structural problems or inconsistencies in the roof deck, and addressing them proactively.

They also provide invaluable guidance in material selection, helping homeowners choose the most appropriate roofing system for their specific needs and budget.

Precise Slope Verification: A Non-Negotiable Step

During installation, the planned roof slope must be diligently verified to ensure compliance with design specifications and building codes. Relying solely on visual estimation is insufficient. Precise measurement is essential.

Utilizing a Roofing Square

A roofing square is a specialized tool designed for accurately measuring roof pitch and slope. Its use during installation allows contractors to confirm that the roof is being constructed to the specified angle. Regular checks with a roofing square are vital to catch any deviations from the planned slope early on, preventing costly rework later.

Employing Other Appropriate Tools

In addition to a roofing square, other tools such as digital levels, laser levels, and inclinometers can also be used to verify roof slope.

The choice of tool depends on the complexity of the roof design and the contractor’s preferred methods.

The important factor is that a reliable method is used to guarantee accuracy throughout the installation process.

By prioritizing proper planning, engaging qualified roofing contractors, and meticulously verifying the roof slope during installation, homeowners can safeguard their investment and ensure the long-term performance and durability of their roof. Cutting corners during the installation phase can have devastating consequences.

Addressing Existing Roofs with Insufficient Slope

Discovering that an existing roof lacks sufficient slope can be a homeowner’s or building manager’s unwelcome surprise. This deficiency, often revealed during inspections or after the onset of leaks, necessitates careful consideration of available remedies. Ignoring the problem invites a cascade of issues.

While preventative measures are ideal, understanding how to address existing deficiencies is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the building.

Evaluating the Problem and Its Scope

Before embarking on any corrective action, a thorough assessment of the roof’s condition is paramount. This evaluation should encompass several key areas:

  • Determining the Actual Slope: A precise measurement of the existing roof slope is essential. This establishes the degree of non-compliance with code or manufacturer recommendations.

  • Identifying the Cause of the Problem: Is the insufficient slope a result of original design flaws, structural sagging, or alterations over time? Understanding the root cause guides the selection of the most effective solution.

  • Assessing Damage: A comprehensive inspection of the roof deck, underlayment, and surrounding structures is crucial to identify any existing water damage or structural compromise. This damage must be addressed concurrently with the slope correction.

Re-roofing with Slope-Suitable Materials

One common approach to addressing insufficient slope is to replace the existing roofing material with one that is designed to perform effectively at lower slopes. This strategy avoids the need for costly and disruptive structural modifications.

Low-Slope Roofing Options

Several roofing materials are specifically engineered for low-slope applications:

  • Built-Up Roofing (BUR): Consisting of multiple layers of roofing felt saturated with asphalt, BUR systems provide excellent waterproofing and durability, even at minimal slopes.

  • Modified Bitumen: Similar to BUR but incorporating polymers for enhanced flexibility and strength, modified bitumen is another popular choice for low-slope roofs.

  • Single-Ply Membranes (TPO, PVC, EPDM): These synthetic rubber or plastic membranes offer exceptional water resistance and are lightweight, making them suitable for various roof structures.

Selecting the appropriate low-slope roofing material requires careful consideration of factors such as climate, budget, and aesthetic preferences.

Modifying the Roof Structure

In some cases, the most effective solution is to alter the roof structure itself to increase the slope. This approach involves physically raising a portion of the roof to achieve the desired pitch.

Structural Adjustments

Structural modifications can range from relatively minor adjustments to more extensive reconstruction.

  • Adding Rafters or Trusses: Installing additional structural members can effectively increase the slope of the roof plane.

  • Raising the Entire Roof Deck: In situations where the existing slope is severely inadequate, it may be necessary to raise the entire roof deck, creating a steeper pitch.

  • Creating a "False" Roof: A new sloped roof structure can be built over the existing flat or low-sloped roof. This effectively adds a second roof with the desired pitch.

Structural modifications demand meticulous planning, engineering expertise, and adherence to building codes. It is imperative to engage qualified professionals to ensure the structural integrity and safety of the roof.

Specialized Waterproofing Systems

For roofs with minor slope deficiencies or where structural alterations are impractical, specialized waterproofing systems can provide an effective solution.

Liquid-Applied Membranes

These systems involve applying a seamless, waterproof coating directly to the roof surface. The coating cures to form a durable, flexible membrane that effectively seals the roof and prevents water intrusion.

Considerations

  • Surface Preparation: Proper surface preparation is critical for the successful application and longevity of liquid-applied membranes.

  • Product Selection: Selecting a high-quality product specifically designed for low-slope applications is essential.

Liquid-applied membranes offer a relatively cost-effective and less disruptive alternative to structural modifications.

However, they may require periodic recoating to maintain their effectiveness.

Professional Consultation Is Key

Addressing insufficient roof slope is a complex undertaking that requires careful planning, informed decision-making, and skilled execution. Engaging a qualified roofing contractor or structural engineer is essential to determine the most appropriate and effective solution for a particular situation.

These professionals can assess the roof’s condition, evaluate potential remedies, and ensure that all work is performed in compliance with building codes and manufacturer recommendations.

FAQs About Minimum Roof Slope

Have more questions about minimum roof slopes? We’ve compiled these frequently asked questions to help clarify some common points.

What happens if my roof’s slope is below the minimum requirement?

If your roof slope is below the minimum slope for roof specified by your roofing material manufacturer, you risk leaks and premature roof failure. Water can pool, seep under shingles, and damage the underlayment and structure below. Always adhere to manufacturer guidelines for minimum slope.

Why do different roofing materials have different minimum roof slopes?

Different roofing materials have varying minimum slope requirements due to their water shedding capabilities. Materials like asphalt shingles need a steeper slope to quickly shed water, while metal roofs can handle flatter slopes due to their interlocking design and water-resistant properties.

Does the minimum slope for roof include the slope tolerance allowed?

No, the minimum slope for roof does not generally include any tolerance. It represents the absolute minimum acceptable slope. It’s crucial to aim for a slope slightly above the minimum to ensure proper drainage, even with minor variations in installation.

What if I want to use a material that requires a steeper minimum slope than my roof currently has?

If your current roof slope is too shallow for your desired roofing material, you’ll need to modify the roof structure to increase the slope. This can be a significant undertaking, potentially involving reframing or adding additional layers. Consult with a qualified roofing contractor for options and cost estimates.

So there you have it! Hopefully, now you’ve got a much clearer picture of the world of minimum slope for roof. Go forth and build…or hire someone who knows what they’re doing!

Leave a Comment