The installation of luxury vinyl plank (LVP) presents homeowners with options, particularly concerning adhesion: lvp glue down vs floating. Armstrong Flooring offers both types of LVP, each with distinct characteristics. The selection process often involves evaluating subfloor moisture levels, a critical attribute that influences long-term performance. Comparing lvp glue down vs floating requires considering the installation method’s impact on acoustic properties, a key value for many consumers. Ultimately, deciding between lvp glue down vs floating significantly impacts the flooring’s longevity and overall aesthetic.
Image taken from the YouTube channel the home collective. , from the video titled Glue Down vs Floating: Which Vinyl Plank is right for you? .
LVP: Glue Down vs Floating – Which Flooring Reigns Supreme?
Understanding the nuances between glue-down and floating Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) installations is critical for a successful flooring project. Choosing the right method depends on various factors, including subfloor condition, moisture levels, room size, and anticipated foot traffic. This article breaks down the differences between these two popular LVP installation methods, enabling you to make an informed decision for your space.
Understanding Glue-Down LVP Installation
Glue-down LVP involves adhering individual planks directly to the subfloor using a specialized adhesive. This creates a strong, stable bond, offering several advantages, but also some drawbacks.
Preparation and Installation Process
- Subfloor Preparation: This is arguably the most crucial step. The subfloor must be clean, level, and dry. Any imperfections, such as cracks, bumps, or loose materials, need to be addressed before installation. This may involve patching, leveling compounds, or even subfloor replacement.
- Adhesive Selection: Choosing the correct adhesive is vital. Different adhesives are designed for specific LVP types and subfloor materials. Consult the LVP manufacturer’s recommendations.
- Application and Curing: The adhesive is applied to the subfloor in sections, and the LVP planks are carefully placed on top, ensuring proper alignment and contact. A roller is often used to press the planks firmly into the adhesive. The adhesive needs time to cure properly before foot traffic is allowed.
Advantages of Glue-Down LVP
- Enhanced Stability: The direct bond to the subfloor provides exceptional stability, making it ideal for high-traffic areas and commercial spaces.
- Dimensional Stability: Glue-down LVP is less susceptible to expansion and contraction due to temperature and humidity changes, minimizing the risk of gapping or buckling.
- Direct Contact with Subfloor: This allows for optimal heat transfer in radiant heat flooring systems.
- Quiet Underfoot: The direct adhesion helps to reduce sound transmission compared to floating floors.
- Lower Profile: Glue-down LVP typically has a lower profile than floating floors, which can be important when transitioning to other flooring types.
Disadvantages of Glue-Down LVP
- Labor-Intensive Installation: Proper subfloor preparation and meticulous adhesive application require significant time and skill, making professional installation highly recommended.
- Difficult Removal: Removing glue-down LVP can be challenging and messy, often requiring specialized tools and potentially damaging the subfloor.
- Subfloor Imperfections: Even minor subfloor imperfections can telegraph through the LVP, affecting its appearance and longevity if preparation is not thorough.
- Potential Adhesive Issues: Incorrect adhesive selection or application can lead to bonding failures.
- Higher Cost: Generally, glue-down LVP installations tend to be more expensive due to increased labor and preparation costs.
Understanding Floating LVP Installation
Floating LVP, on the other hand, doesn’t require adhesive. Instead, the planks interlock using a tongue-and-groove system or a click-lock mechanism. This "floats" the floor above the subfloor.
Preparation and Installation Process
- Subfloor Preparation: While not as critical as with glue-down, the subfloor still needs to be reasonably level, clean, and dry. Minor imperfections can often be addressed with an underlayment.
- Underlayment: An underlayment is typically installed beneath the LVP to provide cushioning, sound insulation, and moisture protection. The type of underlayment depends on the specific LVP product and subfloor conditions.
- Click-Lock System: The planks are aligned and then "clicked" together, creating a secure, interlocking seam.
- Expansion Gap: An expansion gap is left around the perimeter of the room to allow for natural expansion and contraction.
Advantages of Floating LVP
- Easier Installation: Floating LVP is generally easier and faster to install than glue-down, making it a popular choice for DIY projects.
- Less Subfloor Preparation: It’s more forgiving of minor subfloor imperfections as the underlayment can compensate.
- Easy Removal: Floating LVP can be disassembled and removed relatively easily, making it a good option for temporary installations or if you anticipate changing the flooring in the future.
- Cost-Effective: Installation costs are typically lower due to reduced labor and preparation requirements.
- Comfort Underfoot: The underlayment provides added cushioning and warmth.
Disadvantages of Floating LVP
- Less Stable: Compared to glue-down, floating LVP is less stable and may be more prone to movement or shifting under heavy loads.
- More Susceptible to Expansion/Contraction: Temperature and humidity changes can cause the planks to expand and contract, potentially leading to gapping or buckling if an adequate expansion gap is not provided.
- Hollow Sound: Floating LVP can sometimes produce a hollow sound when walked upon, especially if the subfloor is uneven or the underlayment is inadequate.
- Not Ideal for Radiant Heat: While some floating LVP products are compatible with radiant heat, heat transfer is generally less efficient than with glue-down installations.
- Higher Profile: With the addition of underlayment, floating LVP has a higher profile than glue-down, which can affect transitions to other flooring types.
Key Differences Summarized
The following table provides a concise summary of the key differences between glue-down and floating LVP installations:
| Feature | Glue-Down LVP | Floating LVP |
|---|---|---|
| Installation Difficulty | More difficult, requires professional expertise | Easier, suitable for DIY |
| Subfloor Prep | Critical, must be level and clean | Less critical, underlayment can compensate |
| Stability | Very stable | Less stable |
| Removal | Difficult, potentially damaging | Easier, can be disassembled |
| Cost | Higher (material + labor) | Lower (material + labor) |
| Sound | Quieter | Potentially hollow sound |
| Moisture Resistance | Excellent (when proper adhesive used) | Good (depends on product & underlayment) |
| Radiant Heat | Excellent | Good (check manufacturer’s specifications) |
| Profile | Lower | Higher (due to underlayment) |
FAQs: LVP Glue Down vs Floating Flooring
This section addresses common questions about choosing between glue down and floating LVP flooring. We aim to provide clear and concise answers to help you make the best decision for your project.
What is the main difference between glue down and floating LVP flooring?
The primary difference is the installation method. Glue down LVP is directly adhered to the subfloor with adhesive. Floating LVP, on the other hand, clicks or locks together and sits on top of the subfloor without any glue or nails.
Which LVP installation method is better for areas with moisture?
Glue down LVP is generally considered superior for areas prone to moisture, like bathrooms or basements. The direct adhesion creates a tighter seal against the subfloor, reducing the risk of water seeping underneath and causing damage, compared to floating lvp.
Is floating LVP easier to install than glue down LVP?
Yes, floating LVP is typically easier and faster to install for DIYers. The click-lock system simplifies the process, while glue down LVP requires more precise application of adhesive and careful alignment.
When should I choose glue down LVP over floating?
Choose glue down LVP when you need maximum stability, durability, and moisture resistance. It’s ideal for high-traffic areas, commercial spaces, or rooms with uneven subfloors. Although glue down lvp requires more skill to install, it creates a more permanent and robust floor.
Alright, hopefully, you now have a clearer picture of the lvp glue down vs floating debate! Weigh the pros and cons based on your needs and you’ll be sure to make the right choice for your project. Happy flooring!