The choice between toilet seat elongated vs round often depends on bathroom space, a crucial attribute. American Standard, a leading manufacturer of bathroom fixtures, offers both styles catering to diverse customer preferences. The ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) guidelines specify requirements that sometimes favor elongated designs for accessibility. Bathroom design considerations such as aesthetics and comfort drive consumer decisions when evaluating which type of toilet seat elongated vs round is best suited for their needs.
Image taken from the YouTube channel Plumbing Deals , from the video titled Round vs. Elongated Toilets. How do you choose? .
Choosing Between Elongated and Round Toilet Seats: A Comprehensive Guide
The decision of which toilet seat to purchase—elongated or round—often comes down to a mix of personal preference, space constraints, and budget. This guide provides an objective analysis of both types, considering various factors to help you make an informed choice.
Understanding the Basic Differences
The primary difference between elongated and round toilet seats is their shape and size. This fundamental distinction influences comfort, bathroom aesthetics, and even accessibility.
-
Elongated Toilet Seats: These seats are oval-shaped and extend further out from the toilet bowl compared to round seats. They typically measure around 18.5 inches from the mounting holes to the front of the seat.
-
Round Toilet Seats: These seats are circular and more compact. Their length from the mounting holes to the front is approximately 16.5 inches.
Evaluating Comfort and Ergonomics
Comfort is a crucial consideration, especially given the frequency of toilet usage. The shape of the seat can significantly impact user experience.
Comfort Factors
-
Elongated: Generally considered more comfortable by adults due to the increased surface area providing better thigh support. The extended length aligns better with the natural contours of the body.
-
Round: Can be less comfortable for some adults, particularly taller individuals or those with larger builds. However, they can be suitable for children due to their smaller size.
Accessibility Considerations
- For individuals with mobility issues or disabilities, an elongated seat may provide greater ease of use and support during transfers.
Assessing Space and Bathroom Layout
The size and layout of your bathroom play a significant role in determining the best toilet seat shape.
Space Efficiency
-
Round: Best suited for smaller bathrooms where space is limited. Their compact design allows for more clearance and prevents the toilet from protruding excessively into the room.
-
Elongated: Require more space. In tight bathrooms, they can make maneuvering difficult. Ensure adequate clearance in front of the toilet before opting for an elongated seat.
Visual Harmony
- Consider the existing fixtures in your bathroom. If your sink or other elements have rounded edges, a round toilet seat might create a more cohesive aesthetic. Conversely, elongated seats can complement more angular or modern designs.
Examining Cost and Availability
The price and availability of both types of toilet seats can vary depending on the features and materials.
Pricing Trends
- Generally, round toilet seats tend to be slightly less expensive than elongated ones. This difference is usually not substantial, but it can be a factor for budget-conscious buyers.
Variety and Options
- Both elongated and round toilet seats are widely available in a variety of materials (plastic, wood, padded), colors, and features (soft-close hinges, bidet attachments). You’ll typically find a similar range of options for both shapes.
Analyzing Compatibility and Installation
Ensuring the correct fit is essential for proper toilet seat function.
Toilet Bowl Shape
- It’s critical to match the toilet seat shape to the shape of your toilet bowl. An elongated seat on a round bowl (or vice versa) will result in an improper fit, leading to instability and potential damage. Most toilets are either round or elongated.
Measurement Guidelines
- To determine your bowl shape, measure the distance from the center of the mounting holes to the front edge of the bowl. Approximately 16.5 inches indicates a round bowl, while 18.5 inches suggests an elongated one.
Installation Process
- The installation process is generally the same for both elongated and round toilet seats. Most seats come with standard mounting hardware and instructions.
Elongated vs. Round Toilet Seat: Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions to help you decide between an elongated or round toilet seat. We’ll clarify key differences and considerations to make your choice easier.
Does an elongated toilet seat fit all toilets?
No, an elongated toilet seat is longer than a round seat, so it requires more space. While they can often be installed on standard toilets, be sure to measure your toilet’s bowl before purchasing to ensure a proper fit. Consider a round toilet seat if space is limited.
Are elongated toilet seats more hygienic than round toilet seats?
Hygiene depends more on cleaning habits than the shape of the toilet seat. However, some find the slightly larger surface area of an elongated toilet seat easier to keep clean, as it provides more room to maneuver during cleaning.
Are round toilet seats cheaper than elongated toilet seats?
Generally, round toilet seats are often slightly more affordable than elongated models. This is due to the simpler design and potentially less material used in manufacturing. The difference in price between a toilet seat elongated vs round tends to be minimal.
Which style is generally recommended for accessibility?
Elongated toilet seats are often recommended for individuals with mobility issues or disabilities. The extra length can provide additional comfort and support, making them easier to use. Therefore, when comparing toilet seat elongated vs round options for accessibility, elongated is frequently favored.
So, there you have it! Deciding between a toilet seat elongated vs round comes down to personal preference and your specific bathroom setup. Hope this helped you make the right choice!